Why "I'm Fine" Is the Most Dangerous Phrase in Your Organization

By Eric Brooker | Keynote Speaker, Author of You Are Enough, Host of Counsel Culture Podcast

---

Two words. Two syllables. The most common — and most dishonest — answer to the question "How are you?"

"I'm fine."

We say it dozens of times a week. We say it when we're exhausted. We say it when our marriage is crumbling. We say it when we just got devastating news from the doctor. We say it when we haven't spoken to our child in years.

I know, because I said it for a very long time.

The Strategy of Hiding

My wife Jen and I developed what I now call our hiding strategy. For years, we carried the weight of an estranged relationship with my oldest daughter — a pain I wouldn't wish on anyone. When we met new people through church, through the kids' school, through social settings, the conversations always followed the same pattern: Where do you live? Are you married? Do you have kids?

We'd tell people we live in Minnesota, that we're married, that we have seven children. And then the follow-up: Where does your oldest go?

That's where the mask went on.

Rather than share the painful truth, we crafted a story. We didn't mean to lie — it just happened. The alternative felt too heavy, too embarrassing, too isolating. So we performed the version of our life that was easier for everyone to digest.

And here's what that cost us: authentic connection with the very people who could have supported us. By not sharing our real story, we were robbing ourselves of the community we desperately needed and robbing others of the opportunity to say, "Me too."

Your Organization Is Full of People Who Are "Fine"

Now take that dynamic and multiply it across your entire company.

The manager who just learned her father has Alzheimer's — she's "fine."

The top performer whose wife moved out last weekend — he's "crushing it."

The new hire who is drowning in imposter syndrome and terrified of asking for help — she's "getting the hang of things."

Everyone is going through something. That's not pessimism; it's reality. And when your culture doesn't create space for people to be honest about what they're carrying, they hide. They perform. They say "I'm fine."

And here's what happens next: engagement drops. Connection disappears. People feel alone in a room full of colleagues. Culture becomes superficial — all shuffleboard tables and free snacks on the surface, but hollow underneath.

I've been in that environment. I once took a job at a company where everything looked incredible on the outside. The kitchen was stocked with free food, the lobby had a shuffleboard table, and the bookshelves were packed with leadership books. It took about two weeks for the rose-colored glasses to come off. The culture was toxic, the leadership was hollow, and the "fine" everyone was projecting was a lie.

What Authenticity Actually Looks Like

Being authentic doesn't mean dumping your entire life story on a coworker at the coffee machine. It doesn't mean turning every team meeting into a therapy session. It means creating an environment where people don't have to pretend.

It starts at the top. When a leader shares something real — not polished, not curated, but genuinely real — it gives everyone else permission to do the same. Vulnerability begets vulnerability. I've seen it happen in every keynote I deliver. The moment I share my own story, something shifts in the room. Shoulders relax. Eyes get misty. Someone nods and mouths "me too."

Here are three things leaders can do immediately:

Ask better questions. "How are you?" invites "I'm fine." Try instead: "What's been the hardest part of your week?" or "What's weighing on you right now?" These questions signal that you actually want to know.

Go first. Share something you're working through — not to burden your team, but to model that it's OK to be human. I started sharing my story about my daughter, and nearly every time, someone in the room has been through something eerily similar.

Listen without fixing. When someone does open up, resist the urge to immediately solve the problem. Sometimes the most powerful thing you can do is simply listen. A highway patrol officer once saved a man's life on the Golden Gate Bridge not by offering solutions but by listening for ninety-two minutes. When asked what got through, the man said, "You listened to me."

The Business Case for Killing "I'm Fine"

This isn't just a feel-good initiative. Organizations where people feel safe to be authentic outperform those where people hide. The data is clear: psychological safety — the belief that you won't be punished for showing vulnerability — is the number one predictor of high-performing teams.

When people stop performing "fine" and start being real, trust deepens. Collaboration improves. People take smarter risks. Retention increases because people don't leave organizations where they feel seen — they leave organizations where they feel invisible.

Every day, leaders have a choice. You can accept the "I'm fine" at face value and move on with your day. Or you can stop, be present, and create a moment where someone feels safe enough to be honest.

The little things don't mean a lot. The little things mean everything.

And asking one genuine question — then actually listening to the answer — might be the most important little thing you do today.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I create psychological safety without crossing professional boundaries?

Creating psychological safety doesn't mean becoming everyone's therapist. It means establishing norms where honesty is valued and vulnerability isn't punished. Start with how you respond when someone shares something difficult — listen, acknowledge, and ask how you can support them. The boundary is simple: you're creating space, not providing clinical care.

What if my team isn't ready for vulnerability?

They might not be — yet. Vulnerability is built through consistency, not a single initiative. Start small. Share something real about your own experience. Don't force others to reciprocate. Over time, when people see that honesty is met with grace rather than judgment, the walls start coming down.

How does hiding affect organizational performance?

When people hide their struggles, they also hide their ideas, their concerns, and their best thinking. Inauthenticity creates a culture of self-protection rather than contribution. Research consistently shows that teams where people feel safe to be honest outperform teams where people perform "fine."

---

Eric Brooker is the preeminent voice on leadership, culture, and worthiness. Learn more at ericbrooker.com or book Eric for your next event at ericbrooker.com/contact.